Softball: 2025 Miss Indiana Finalists Named

(6-5-25) The Softball Coaches of Indiana announced their 2025 Indiana All-Star teams and the five finalist for the 2025 Indiana Miss Softball award.

Each of the five district are allowed one finalist for the senior-only award as voted upon on by their respective coaches.

The winner of this year’s award will be announced at the SCAI All-Star games 21 at IU’s Andy Mohr Field in Bloomington.

2025 Miss Indiana Finalist

Geyer, Zachary, Neal, Stieneker and Marx

• Ava Geyer – New Prairie
• Ava Zachary – Penn
• Izzy Neal – Brownsburg
• Addison Stieneker – Shelbyville
• Katelyn Marx – Tecumseh

Indy Star – Meet the five finalists for 2025 Indiana Miss Softball

The Indiana All-Star Weekend is scheduled for June 20th and 21st at IU’s Andy Mohr Field in Bloomington.

North in Blue & South in Red

*** Indicates a player is a finalist for the 2025 Indiana Miss Softball award

• 2024 – Audrey Lowry – Tri-West High School
• 2023 – Keagan Rothrock – Roncalli

Audrey Lowry, 2024 Indiana Miss Softball! Tri-West is proud of you! @TriWestSoftball @ScottFrye37 @nwhsc1 pic.twitter.com/voq1yYm0sD

— Tri-West High School Athletics (@triwestsports) June 22, 2024

Also, adding to the long list of awards Keagan has earned, she was named the 2023 Indiana’s Miss Softball. An honor only bestowed upon one other Roncalli player, Kendra Lynch, a 2013 graduate. pic.twitter.com/FmaiZrXuE4

— Roncalli High School (@roncallihigh) July 3, 2023

Congratulations to this years Indiana Miss Softball from Shelbyville HS, Karissa Hamilton!! @shelbyhsbears pic.twitter.com/tsKlhOFrn3

— Softball Coaches Association of Indiana (@SCAIndiana) June 25, 2022