(11-16-26) The decades-long debate over separating Ohio’s public and private schools in the postseason is now one step from a statewide vote.
The Suburban League submitted its petition to the OHSAA on Monday, Nov. 16, with 152 signatures from high school principals — more than double the 75 needed — seeking a membership vote in May 2027 on separate state tournaments for public and private schools. If the measure reaches the ballot and passes, separate tournaments would begin with the 2028-29 school year.
The filing comes two weeks ahead of the petition’s Dec. 1 deadline. WCPO 9 in Cincinnati first reported the submission late Monday afternoon, and Q92 Sports in the Youngstown area also reported the petition as filed Monday.
What happens next
The OHSAA must still verify the signatures before the question goes on the ballot. Only principals can sign, and the petition needs at least 75 signatures with at least five from each of the OHSAA’s six athletic districts. OHSAA spokesman Tim Stried has said the Board of Directors will wait until the petition is formalized before making any comment.
“The petition itself is not the vote, which would take place next May if they get enough signatures,” Stried said last month. “If the vote becomes imminent, the OHSAA will release more information and explain what separate tournaments would mean, including potential unintended consequences.”
If it reaches the ballot, the OHSAA’s annual referendum voting period runs May 1-15, 2027. Each member school gets one vote, cast by its high school principal, and the OHSAA constitution requires every member high school to submit a ballot.
What the proposal would do
The petition would add language to the OHSAA bylaws — proposed bylaw 2-2-1 — classifying every member school as either Public or Non-Public for tournament competition. Public schools would include traditional district schools and community (charter) schools; non-public schools would include both chartered and nonchartered private schools.
The separation would operate within the OHSAA’s current divisional framework, and both groups would remain OHSAA members — this is a split of the postseason tournaments, not a split of the association. The OHSAA’s competitive balance system, which adjusts enrollment figures for private schools and open-enrollment publics in football, basketball, soccer, volleyball, softball and baseball, would end after the 2027-28 school year.
The petition’s stated purpose, presented to administrators this fall, is “to provide equal opportunities for all schools throughout the state of Ohio to compete for a state championship.”
The numbers behind the push
The OHSAA has 812 member high schools — 691 public and 121 private, meaning private schools make up less than 15 percent of the membership. The petition’s presentation notes that private schools won 36 of the 98 team state titles in 2025-26.
Nordonia athletic director Rob Eckenrode, one of the leaders of the petition drive, put it this way to the Akron Beacon Journal: “We’re just looking for equity throughout high school sports. There’s plenty of recruiting bylaws in place for the OHSAA. We just want them all to be abided by. Unfortunately, people are not playing by the same rules. It’s either split or everybody abides by the same rules.”
“Less than 15% of OHSAA member are private schools,” Eckenrode added. “Private schools are still making up 35% of state champions.”
Who is behind it
The petition was organized by superintendents, principals and athletic directors from the Suburban League, a Northeast Ohio conference whose schools include Aurora, Barberton, Brecksville-Broadview Heights, Copley, Highland, Hudson, Kenston, North Royalton, Nordonia, Mayfield, Medina, Revere, Solon, Stow-Munroe Falls and Twinsburg. Every Suburban League school is involved except Wadsworth, which specifically asked not to be included in the petition, the referendum item or the process.
The history
This is the third time the question has been put to OHSAA members. Similar referendums to split public and private schools failed in 1978 and 1993.
A push from Wayne County schools about a decade ago took a different path, leading to the competitive balance system established in 2017. That system adjusts enrollment totals on a sport-by-sport basis, but it applies only to six team sports — football, basketball, soccer, volleyball, softball and baseball.
The reaction so far
OHSAA executive director Doug Ute has said the OHSAA office is not taking a position on the petition.
Among Greater Akron athletic directors surveyed by the Beacon Journal last month, opinion was split. Norton AD Travis Dobbins said he has “mixed emotions” — he sees a need for some division, but worries private schools could leave the OHSAA and form their own organization, free of OHSAA recruiting regulations. “I can see this becoming a bigger issue for public schools, but not necessarily private,” Dobbins said. “If it does happen, I hope private schools will stay as part of the OHSAA and keep the organization strong.”
Hoban, one of Summit County’s four private schools, declined to weigh in until the petition was formalized. Walsh Jesuit withheld comment until it reaches the membership, and Cuyahoga Valley Christian Academy and St. Vincent-St. Mary did not respond.
Manchester AD Brody Jackson, who coached basketball in Virginia in the 2000s under a split public-private system, said he is not ready to support the petition yet. “It’s hard. I think it’s a step in the right direction, but it doesn’t correct all our problems,” Jackson said. “There’s some big public schools that recruit more than private schools these days. I haven’t totally made up my mind on it yet.”
Woodridge AD Nick Mayer, whose school has open enrollment, said the proposal raises as many questions as it answers. “It’s definitely interesting,” Mayer said. “I think there’s a lot of things that can happen. There’s a lot of threats out there. It would be an interesting landscape.”
The Illinois parallel
Ohio is not the only state wrestling with this. In Illinois, the IHSA’s Competitive Balance Committee has recommended putting all non-boundaried private schools into their own bracket quadrant, and the IHSA’s 25 bylaw proposals for 2026-27 include a jump in the private-school multiplier from 1.65 to 2.5 and separate boundaried and non-boundaried classifications. The IHSA commission decides around Nov. 23 which proposals reach the December member ballot.
Sources: WCPO 9 (petition filed with 152 signatures, Nov. 16); Q92 Sports (petition filed, Nov. 16); Akron Beacon Journal, Oct. 28 (petition background, Eckenrode and athletic director reaction); Cincinnati Enquirer, Sept. 16 (petition mechanics, Dec. 1 deadline, bylaw language); OHSAA presentation on the petition’s rationale.
Muse AI assisted
