(11-19-26) The vote is official. On Wednesday, Nov. 18, the OHSAA confirmed it has received a completed petition that will force a referendum vote of its member schools next May on separating public and non-public schools into separate divisions for postseason tournaments.

So who are the private schools at the center of the debate? Here’s a look at the OHSAA’s non-public membership.

The membership

The OHSAA has 813 member high schools — 691 public and 121 non-public, per the association’s Nov. 18 release. That makes private schools just under 15 percent of the membership.

The 121 are a mix: Catholic diocesan and parochial schools (the Archbishop and Bishop schools, the Catholic Centrals, the St. schools), Christian academies, and independent prep schools such as Columbus Academy, Cincinnati Country Day and Andrews Osborne Academy.

They run the full range of sizes. Bishop Rosecrans in Zanesville lists 44 boys and 39 girls in the OHSAA’s 2026-27 enrollment figures. At the other end, all-boys Archbishop Moeller in Cincinnati lists 705 boys, and St. Xavier in Cincinnati is among the largest schools in the state. Some are single-sex: Beaumont School in Cleveland Heights (227 girls) and Columbus School for Girls (148 girls) field only girls teams, while Moeller and Benedictine in Cleveland are all-boys.

The big names are familiar to anyone who follows Ohio football: St. Edward, St. Ignatius, St. Xavier, Moeller, Elder, Hoban, Watterson and Toledo Central Catholic.

The numbers behind the debate

Private schools are about 15 percent of the membership — but they have won far more than 15 percent of the state titles in the OHSAA’s competitive balance sports (football, volleyball, soccer, basketball, baseball and softball).

Per the OHSAA, from the 2001-02 school year through 2016-17, private schools won 44 percent of the state championships in those sports. Since competitive balance went into effect in 2017-18, that share has dropped to 34 percent — public schools have won 66 percent.

The per-sport picture varies widely. In football, private schools won 57 of 112 titles (50.9 percent) from 1999-2000 through 2016-17; in the competitive balance era (2017-18 through 2025-26), they have won 13 of 63 (20.6 percent). Girls volleyball still leans private: 27 of 42 titles (64.3 percent) in the competitive balance era. Softball is at the other extreme — private schools have won just 2 of 38 titles (5.3 percent) since 2017-18.

And last school year, per the petition presentation, private schools won 36 of the 98 team state titles awarded in 2025-26.

What May decides

The referendum voting period runs May 1-15, 2027. Each member high school principal casts one vote, and a simple majority passes the item. If it passes, separate tournaments would take effect with the 2028-29 school year; the OHSAA Board of Directors would determine how many divisions public and private schools get in each sport, and the competitive balance process would be eliminated.

This is the third time the question has gone to the membership. Separation was defeated in 1978 by 83.9 percent to 16.1 percent, and again in 1993 by 66.8 percent to 33.2 percent. The OHSAA notes that eight states currently have some form of separate tournaments for public and private schools.

The OHSAA office is no longer neutral. It was apparent when the OHSAA sent out the press release—- OHSAA Receives Completed Petition to Force Referendum Vote

Executive Director Doug Ute said in the Nov. 18 release:

“Are there differences between public and private schools? Yes, but we believe that separate tournaments would have some negative unintended consequences…the non-public divisions could have a low number of schools per division and a large enrollment disparity within divisions.”

The OHSAA plans a series of meetings with member schools in early 2027 to walk through the proposal before the vote.

Related: OHSAA Receives Completed Petition For Separate Tournaments Vote

Sources: OHSAA news release, Nov. 18, 2026 (petition received, membership figures, vote mechanics, title splits, Ute quotes); OHSAA 2026-27 school enrollment figures (school sizes); Cincinnati Enquirer, Sept. 18, 2026 (per-sport championship breakdowns from OHSAA competitive balance data); petition presentation figures reported Nov. 16 (36 of 98 titles in 2025-26).